Circumcision of the Heart: What It Means for Inner Transformation in Faith
Please note that this article may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn on qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. You can read more at the bottom of this page or read my full disclosure on my Affiliate Disclosure Page
When we encounter the phrase “circumcision of the heart,” it may seem unfamiliar or even confusing. But this powerful metaphor is deeply rooted in both the Tanakh (Old Testament) and the New Testament, pointing to an essential aspect of spiritual transformation.
For believers in Yeshua (Jesus), circumcision of the heart reflects the inner work of faith, repentance, and renewal that takes place as they draw closer to God. It speaks to the deeper spiritual process that moves beyond physical rituals, inviting all to live lives marked by obedience, humility, and love.
Let’s explore what the Bible teaches about this concept and how it applies to us today.
Be sure to download your free copy of our Circumcision of the Heart study and reflection questions at the end of this post!
The Biblical Origins of Circumcision of the Heart
The Old Testament Significance
The tradition of circumcision, or brit milah (בְּרִית מִילָה), holds a central place in Jewish identity, symbolizing the covenant between God and His people.
Introduced in Bereishit (Genesis) 17:9-14, God commands Abraham to circumcise all male descendants on the eighth day (yom ha-shmini, יום הַשְּׁמִינִי). This physical act serves as an outward sign of the covenant between God and Israel, marking them as a people set apart for His purposes.
The term brit (בְּרִית) means “covenant,” and milah (מִילָה) refers to “circumcision,” representing the binding agreement to walk in God’s ways. The practice of circumcision of the flesh was an external reminder of this sacred commitment.
However, as the Hebrew Scriptures progress, the prophets and leaders of Israel call for something deeper—milat halev (מִילַת הַלֵּב), the circumcision of the heart.
In Deuteronomy 10:16, Moses urges the Israelites to “circumcise the foreskin of your heart” and no longer be stubborn, emphasizing that physical circumcision alone was not enough.
The Hebrew word lev (לֵב), meaning “heart,” symbolizes the core of one’s being—emotions, intellect, and will. God desired not just physical compliance with the covenant but an internal transformation of the heart.
In Leviticus 26:41, God addresses Israel’s rebellion, referring to their “uncircumcised hearts,” showing that the absence of true repentance and humility was a spiritual barrier. This idea underscores that outward ritual must be accompanied by inward devotion—a heart fully aligned with God’s will.
Circumcision of the heart in the Tanakh pointed to a deeper need for purity, humility, and obedience, a theme that would carry through the prophets and into the New Testament teachings.
This duality—physical circumcision as a sign of the covenant and circumcision of the heart as a sign of inward devotion—shows that the covenant was always meant to be more than external. It calls for an internal transformation that mirrors the external sign of belonging to God, pointing toward a life marked by faith, repentance, and submission to His will.
The New Testament Fulfillment
The concept of circumcision of the heart is fulfilled and reframed in the New Testament. The Apostle Paul, who was deeply rooted in Jewish tradition as a Jew himself as well as a Pharisee, carries this theme forward, particularly in his letter to the Romans.
In Romans 2:28-29, he writes:
“For one is not a Jew who is one outwardly, nor is circumcision something visible in the flesh. Rather, the Jew is one inwardly, and circumcision is of the heart—in Spirit not in letter.”
tlv
When Paul speaks about circumcision of the heart in Romans 2:29, it’s important to understand the context. Paul is not saying that anyone who merely considers themselves a Jew is truly a Jew.
Rather, he is addressing Jewish believers here, making the point that physical circumcision alone does not fulfill the covenant if the heart is not aligned with God.
In other words, a Jewish person who has undergone the physical act of circumcision but has not surrendered their heart to God is, in essence, not fulfilling the true spirit of the command.
Paul emphasizes that true circumcision is “of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the letter.” He is reminding his fellow Jews that the covenant requires more than the outward act—it demands inward transformation.
Physical circumcision, while a crucial sign of the covenant, is incomplete if it is not accompanied by a heart that seeks after God. Paul’s words do not undermine the importance of Jewish identity or practice but rather call attention to the deeper, spiritual significance that God has always intended.
This deeper meaning is what believers in Yeshua are called to embrace, recognizing that a heart turned toward God is the ultimate fulfillment of His covenant.
Furthermore, Paul explains that when gentiles turn their hearts to God and live in accordance with His ways, this becomes an inward sign of their covenant through Yeshua. While they may not carry the physical mark of circumcision, their transformed hearts are evidence of their inclusion in God’s covenant through faith in the Messiah.
This heart circumcision is the true mark of belonging to God’s people, for both Jew and Gentile.
In Colossians 2:11, Paul further elaborates that, through Yeshua, believers undergo a spiritual circumcision—“the stripping away of the body of the flesh.”
This is not a mere physical procedure but a metaphor for cutting away the sinful nature, allowing believers to live in the righteousness and freedom of the Messiah.
This inward act of circumcision also surfaces in the preaching of Stephen, the first martyr, in Acts 7:51. Stephen rebukes the religious leaders, saying:
“O you stiff-necked people! You uncircumcised of heart and ears! You always resist the Ruach ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit); just as your fathers did, you do as well.”
TLV (Parentheses mine)
His words echo the call of the prophets and underscore the necessity of inward transformation for a genuine relationship with God.
These prophets emphasized that true obedience to God goes beyond only outward rituals and must include a genuine, humble heart turned toward Him. Some key prophets whose messages Stephen’s words reflect are:
- Jeremiah – In Jeremiah 4:4, the prophet calls the people of Judah to “circumcise yourselves to Adonai and remove the foreskins of your heart,” emphasizing that outward compliance with the law must be accompanied by an inward transformation. Jeremiah also frequently warns of the people’s “stiff-necked” resistance to God’s word (e.g., Jeremiah 6:10, 9:25-26).
- Ezekiel – Ezekiel 44:7-9 speaks of “uncircumcised hearts” and the need for purity in both heart and flesh to approach God. Ezekiel also prophesied that God would give His people a “new heart” and “new spirit” (Ezekiel 36:26), stressing internal renewal over external compliance.
- Isaiah – In Isaiah 6:9-10, the prophet is told that the people have “ears but do not hear” and “hearts that do not understand,” a theme of spiritual deafness and resistance to God’s message, much like the “uncircumcised ears” Stephen speaks of.
These prophets called out Israel’s hardness of heart, urging the people to return to God with sincerity, humility, and true repentance. Stephen’s rebuke draws on these themes, pointing out that some of the religious leaders of his time were continuing the same stubborn resistance to God that their ancestors had shown.
What Does It Mean to Have a Circumcised Heart?
A New Heart Through Faith and Repentance
At its core, the circumcision of the heart refers to the spiritual process of cutting away sin and self-centeredness, making way for a new, redeemed life. This process, however, is not something we can accomplish on our own. It requires faith and a willing submission to God’s work within us.
In Colossians 2:11, Paul describes this transformation as the removal of the “sinful nature.” Just as physical circumcision was a covenant sign for the Jewish people, spiritual circumcision signifies a new covenant through Yeshua for all nations of the earth, marked by repentance and renewal. It is through faith in Yeshua’s death and resurrection that believers receive the gift of a renewed heart, set free from the grip of sin.
All nations You have made will come
psalm 86:9 tlv
and bow down before You, my Lord,
and they will glorify Your Name.
Humility, Faith, Hope, and Love
A circumcised heart naturally leads to the development of key spiritual virtues—humility, faith, hope, and love. In a world that prizes pride, self-sufficiency, and material success, heart circumcision brings believers into a life of humility, recognizing their complete dependence on God’s grace.
Faith flourishes as we learn to trust in God’s promises rather than relying on our own strength. With this transformation, we also gain hope for the future, knowing that God’s redemptive plan is unfolding in our lives. And at the core of it all is love—the love of God that flows into us and overflows into our relationships with others.
Practical Implications of Circumcision of the Heart in Modern Christian Life
Overcoming Pride and Materialism
In today’s society, we are bombarded with messages that encourage us to prioritize personal success, wealth, and recognition. However, the circumcision of the heart helps believers to reject pride and materialism, reminding us that our value and purpose come from God, not from the accumulation of worldly goods or achievements, or likes and comments.
Consider, for example, the many distractions that vie for our attention—social media, entertainment, and the constant drive for success or recognition.
These distractions can pull us away from our spiritual growth, leading us to focus more on outward appearances than on the condition of our hearts. A circumcised heart calls us back to God, helping us strip away those distractions and refocus on what truly matters—our relationship with Him.
Embracing Spiritual Growth and Renewal
A circumcised heart is not a one-time event; it is a daily commitment to spiritual growth. Through prayer, meditation, and reliance on the Holy Spirit, we invite God to continue His transformative work in our hearts. This process of renewal requires a willingness to examine our lives, identify areas that are not aligned with God’s will, and allow Him to “cut away” what is impure.
As believers, we are called to reflect on our spiritual journey regularly, asking ourselves: Are there areas of pride, selfishness, or sin that need to be addressed? How can we allow the Holy Spirit to guide us toward deeper faith and obedience?
By embracing this ongoing transformation, we become more conformed to the image of Yeshua.
Living in Obedience and Love
One of the most tangible results of heart circumcision is a life of obedience and love. In Romans 13:8, Paul reminds us that “the one who loves another has fulfilled the Torah.” Love for others becomes the outworking of a heart that has been transformed by God.
Living in obedience to God’s commands doesn’t mean following a rigid set of rules; rather, it means living out the values of the kingdom—justice, mercy, humility, and love. This obedience flows naturally from a heart that has been circumcised, a heart that desires to honor God in every aspect of life.
Practical ways to live this out include serving others, engaging in acts of kindness, and being a source of encouragement and support within our communities. As we do so, we demonstrate the love of God to the world around us, fulfilling the command to love one another.
Circumcision of the Heart: A Call to Daily Spiritual Discipline
As I mentioned, the circumcision of the heart calls us to more than a one-time spiritual experience; it invites us into a daily practice of self-reflection, repentance, and spiritual discipline.
Just as physical circumcision has always been a mark of the covenant for Abraham’s descendants, spiritual circumcision is a mark of the believer’s relationship with God through Yeshua. But this mark is not physical—it is displayed in our lives through the way we live, love, and follow God’s will.
By making self-examination, repentance, and spiritual growth a regular part of our lives, we maintain a heart that is open to God’s transforming power. It is through this ongoing discipline that we experience the fullness of life in Yeshua and become more like Him in character and action.
Studying Mussar as a Tool for Heart Transformation
In the pursuit of spiritual growth, the ancient Jewish practice of Mussar offers profound insights into cultivating a circumcised heart. Mussar, meaning “discipline” or “ethics,” focuses on character refinement and personal transformation, emphasizing virtues like humility, patience, and gratitude.
The heart circumcision we are called to in Scripture requires a continuous shaping of our inner character, a process that Mussar directly addresses by guiding us to examine and refine our moral and ethical behavior.
By engaging in Mussar study, something I have done for several years with my own rabbi and congregation and teach here at Worth Beyond Rubies absolutely free, believers can gain practical tools for self-reflection and personal accountability.
This spiritual practice encourages us to identify areas of weakness, whether it’s pride, anger, or selfishness, and to actively work toward removing these barriers to godliness.
The discipline of Mussar aligns with the biblical call to “cut away” the sinful parts of our heart, replacing them with virtues that lead us toward love, humility, and spiritual renewal. As we incorporate these teachings into our daily lives, we move closer to embodying the transformation God desires, making Mussar a valuable resource for fostering a truly circumcised heart.
If you would like to join us in Mussar, visit our Mussar page for more details! There is also a place at the end of this post where you can sign up to receive email updates about our program and studies.
We even have a new Mussar for Kids playlist on YouTube so you can begin teaching your kids about the various spiritual traits! Here is a sample of one of our videos!
My Final Thoughts: A Heart Set Apart for God
The circumcision of the heart is a powerful metaphor that challenges us to go beyond outward appearances and focus on the true condition of our hearts. It calls us to a life of inner transformation, where faith, repentance, and love become the guiding principles of our lives.
By committing to this ongoing process of renewal, we set our hearts apart for God’s purposes, living as His faithful servants in a world that desperately needs His love and truth.
Reflection Questions:
- Are there specific areas in my life where I have been resistant to God’s transformative work?
- How can I practice humility, faith, and love in my daily interactions with others?
- What distractions or habits are preventing me from fully dedicating my heart to God?
- In what ways can I actively seek spiritual growth and renewal in my daily life?
- How does the concept of heart circumcision challenge my understanding of obedience to God?
Take some time today to reflect on the state of your heart.
Is there an area where you feel God calling you to deeper obedience or repentance? Commit to allowing the Holy Spirit to work in your heart, cutting away any hindrances to your spiritual growth.
Through prayer, scripture reading, and intentional reflection, ask God to renew your heart and guide you into greater alignment with His will.
Remember, a circumcised heart is not just about what you believe but about how you live. Embrace the journey of inner transformation, knowing that God is faithful to complete the good work He has begun in you.
Don’t forget to download your free copy of our Circumcision of the Heart Bible study and reflection questions below!
Tree of Life (TLV) – Scripture taken from the Holy Scriptures, Tree of Life Version*. Copyright © 2014,2016 by the Tree of Life Bible Society. Used by permission of the Tree of Life Bible Society.